Home » Blogs » Therapy Soup » Girl Declared “Brain-Dead”, Jahi McMath, Is Alive And Responsive

Girl Declared “Brain-Dead”, Jahi McMath, Is Alive And Responsive

1152277_90340870Sam Schmid‘s is a college student who returned from a “brain-dead” coma.

Cases including that of Steven Thorpe, a teen who “came back” after being declared brain dead by four medical experts, as well as Terri Schiavo and Karen Quinlan who were both pulled off life support (and in Terri Schiavo’s situation, that life support consisted of nutritional support) are hotly debated.

Now, five neurologists have declared that young Jahi McMath, who went into a coma during a tonsillectomy, is not brain-dead, and indeed, has been responding to voice commands to move her hands and feet. Yet, a court-appointed neurologist says Jahi is brain dead.

Part of the problem is being sure that the description “brain-dead” is accurate. In Jahi McMath’s case, some doctors say that the original diagnosis was simply incorrect. (Others say Jahi is in fact, dead.)

But if the declaration of death is incorrect in even one out of one hundred cases, that still means that a patient is literally being murdered if taken off supportive medical systems. This is certainly a thorny ethical and moral problem for philosophers, scientists, and most of all doctors, but also an incredibly powerful issue for family members.

Recently, “Scientists in Cambridge have found hidden signatures in the brains of people in a vegetative state, which point to networks that could support consciousness even when a patient appears to be unconscious and unresponsive. The study could help doctors identify patients who are aware despite being unable to communicate.” (See article at

Dr Srivas Chennu from the Department of Clinical Neurosciences at the University of Cambridge, where the study originated, says that “…for patients diagnosed as vegetative and minimally conscious, and their families, this is far more than just an academic question, it takes on a very real significance. Our research could improve clinical assessment and help identify patients who might be covertly aware despite being uncommunicative.”

As someone who believes absolutely in the value of a human life, some of the more disturbing thoughts others have shared with me include:

“If someone is brain-dead they are an “organism” and are no longer human.”

“Anyone who is suffering, whether brain dead or not, should be allowed to have an assisted death.”

Obviously, this is a real issue, with serious moral and ethical considerations.

What do you think?


Girl Declared “Brain-Dead”, Jahi McMath, Is Alive And Responsive

Richard Zwolinski, LMHC, CASAC & C.R. Zwolinski

Richard Zwolinski, LMHC, CASAC is the author of Therapy Revolution: Find Help, Get Better, and Move On Without Wasting Time or Money and is licensed in addiction and psychotherapy with over 25 years experience as well as a consultant to organizations and companies in the fields of mental health and addiction. He is the executive director of an outpatient behavioral health program. Learn more about Richard here.

7 comments: View Comments / Leave a Comment



APA Reference
& C.R. Zwolinski, R. (2014). Girl Declared “Brain-Dead”, Jahi McMath, Is Alive And Responsive. Psych Central. Retrieved on June 2, 2020, from


Last updated: 20 Oct 2014
Statement of review: Psych Central does not review the content that appears in our blog network ( prior to publication. All opinions expressed herein are exclusively those of the author alone, and do not reflect the views of the editorial staff or management of Psych Central. Published on All rights reserved.