Blaming and Finding Fault to Achieve Security and Control
Some children learned that their parents expected them to be “perfect.”
The parents’ may have held overcritical attitudes that led their children to believe, that their faults and imperfections, were a “disappointment”. These children may have come to believe it was their “fault” that they didn’t live up to their high standards and expectations. To relieve their painful feelings of worthlessness, these children may try to deal with the issue of “fault” in immature, inappropriate ways:
1. They may seek to relieve the pain of their faults by striving for perfection.
2. They may try to “deny” that they have faults. They dismiss all accusations of having faults as nonsense triggered by lies or jealousy.
3. They may defensively deny their own imperfections by going on the offensive and blaming others for their difficulties. Their motto is “It’s not my fault. You made me do it!” They cannot see how they may have contributed to their own predicament because they are already filled to the brim with guilt, disappointment or resentment.
4. Conversely they may define themselves as worthless. So they turn their assets into liabilities and take excessive responsibility for others failures and problems.
As life goes on, they carry these childhood lessons with them into adulthood. As a result, they react inappropriately when confronted with the perceived faults or imperfections of others and the world. When something happens in the present to confirm these childhood convictions of fault, they are forced to react.
Fault-finding is a common response when faced with disappointment and inconvenience. Every person approaches a problem or setback in one of two ways. Some focus on the problem or the reason why a problem emerged (problem focused thinking). Others prefer to think about possible solutions that help them to solve a problem (solution focused thinking).
One facet of a problem focused approach is to relieve the discomfort of “not knowing who did it,” by blaming and finding fault. As if such “answers” will provide security and a feeling of being “in control” of a situation.
Another aspect of a problem focused approach is to achieve “fairness.” This motivates us to seek out the “perpetrators” so that we can give them the punishment that they deserve. “How else will they learn the error of their ways?”
This never works. In an imperfect world, imperfect people often make mistakes that are not intentional and therefore, hardly a matter of criminal activity that warrant guilt and punishment. When children knock something over accidentally, is that a fault? Or is it a human imperfection? Do such “faults” have to be “found in the name of “justice?”
The purpose here is not to improve relationships or to secure cooperation, it is to show responsibility. Some take it upon themselves to provide accountability and prevent others from getting away with it, which they assume will avoid more problems in the future.
A third component of a fault based, problem focused approach is the implied superiority that is associated with “judging”. How do you judge superior and inferior in humans? What is the standard? Who is the average person to compare against? The truth is we really do not know what is best. ‘Right’ and ‘wrong’ are absolutes. We have enough trouble figuring out what is best for ourselves, how can we know what best for anyone else.
Our mistake is to take these judgements literally, personally, and serious. When we do, we make the mistake of choosing to plead our case in an imaginary court of law with a judge and jury of one. We make the mistake of defending our innocence to avoid being convicted as guilty and deserving punishment.
The issue is not guilt, fault or blame; the issue is human imperfection. We are still worthwhile human beings in spite of what happened. It was not a crime to make a mistake and we are not guilty.
Karmin, A. (2017). Blaming and Finding Fault to Achieve Security and Control. Psych Central. Retrieved on June 29, 2017, from https://blogs.psychcentral.com/anger/2017/03/blaming-and-finding-fault-to-achieve-security-and-control/