Mindfulness and Psychotherapy

In an age where our lives seem to be accelerating, our stress also naturally seems to be increasing. In addition to addictive behaviors potentially having …

11 Comments to
Mindfulness and Addiction: Part I

Before posting, please read our blog moderation guidelines. The comments below begin with the oldest comments first. Click on the last comments page to jump to the most recent comments.

  • I’m very interested to see how this Mindfulness-based Relapse Prevention stuff will play out. While I’m sure, on a practical level, it’s possible to integrate mindfulness practice and principles into 12-Step programs and government-sanctioned treatment approaches, I also wonder if mindfulness-based approaches to addiction (and mental health issues in general) will prove to be fundamentally at odds with the disease model/brain disorder paradigm that rules the day.

    From my point of view, the growing body of research showing the efficacy of mindfulness approaches to various “problems of living” demands a radical revisioning of addiction and psychiatry in general.

  • I don’t understand your point of view Bob.

  • Speaking as a recovering addict (which certainly doesn’t make me an expert), I think the disease model is in need of revision. Or, if not, our traditional ideas about diseases need revising or expanding. On some level is all just seems like pointless semantics.

    Addiction certainly raises interesting questions about behavior, and it’s roots and causes. Does our genetic inheritance and environmental past work in connection with some mysterious, inner psychological algorithm to influence our behavior? Quite likely. In this view, addiction and disease are labels given by culturally appointed experts to signify our behavior is out of bounds.

    Perhaps addiction is best understood as a disease of free will. That’s how I experienced it at times. I FELT powerless. Whether I was or not is irrelevant in many ways. Leave it to philosophers and neuroscientists to decide.

    Regardless of how you view it, whether you believe in the disease model, powerlessness, self-determination, or whatever… information is an “event”, and as such it has power. The power to affect changes.

    So, maybe the knowledge of “mindfulness” will incline some of us to practice it, and maybe through the practice something will happen… that mysterious “algorithm” will shift slightly, and for the better. In this way mindfulness could essentially come to take the role, for some of us, of what the 12-steppers call a “higher power”.

  • Rita,

    Sorry for being so vague. After fifteen years of working in psychiatric hospitals and other mental health settings, I’ve noticed that the predominant view of psychological problems (and addiction in particular) is that they are primarily matters of chemical imbalance or brain dysfunction/disease. If it’s true that these disorders can be treated or perhaps even “cured” through mindfulness practice, which is simply a shifting of attention and awareness, then that would present quite a challenge (I think) to the whole disease conception of mental problems.

    Hope this is clearer.

  • Thank you all for your comments, this is a place for such rich discussion. I want to add one note here. A cure implies that there is some antidote to a problem that will rid of it forever. When suffering with addiction, cravings and urges may never completely go away forever. They may become less apparent, but they can still rear their heads. This is why so many people continue to find it beneficial to keep connected to community for support. Mindfulness can be thought of more as a way of healing as it’s an active and ongoing practice to support us in changing the way we relate to our stress and pain and therefore breaking the cycle of reactivity.

  • I am reading “the joy of life”

    http://www.amazon.com/Joy-Living-Unlocking-Science-Happiness/dp/B001M5UIW2/

    and I read:

    http://www.amazon.com/Happiness-Guide-Developing-Lifes-Important/dp/0316167258/

    I have been studying Buddhism for 10 years and it has seriously altered my life in a positive way.

    Most of men’s suffering is related to the illusional ego. The whole goal of Buddhism philosophy is to understand that this ego (or self or I) is just a fabrication of the mind and that it causes ignorance about reality, attachment and aversion.

    Unlike all those simplistic religions (Christianity, Islam, Judaism..) Buddhism is no religion (it has no God concept, no dogmas, no fairy tales..) but a very inspiring philosophy of life. That’s why I enjoy it so much.

  • The disease model and the mindfulness model are not so different- the body is the ultimate chemical factory and the physiological mechanisms for influencing changes similar.

  • Jez makes a good point, mindfulness does not necessarily separate from the disease model. Even if the idea is that addiction is a disease, we can still bring nonjudgmental present moment awareness to the triggers, cravings, and urges to support ourselves through this process and make a change. The serenity prayer says “God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference…living one day at a time, enjoying one moment at a time…” Stress reduction informs us to be aware of and accepting of the things we are and are not in control of. This prayer also informs us to do that and be mindful by taking one moment at a time. Whether you believe in the disease model or not, there is no judgment and both can bring more nonjudgmental present moment awareness and compassion into their approach to healing.

  • AMEN SISTER! That about sums it up to the fullest!

  • I struggle with pornography addiction. Mindfulness has helped slightly, though, of course, it hasn’t been “the cure” (see Kabat Zinn’s distinction between “healing” and “curing.”) Debates are raging over whether or not pornography addiction is a real addiction, meanwhile, people struggling with it are being forgotten about in the mix. However, Dr. Michael Twohig did a study on how ACT can help those who suffer from problematic viewing. ACT has a mindfulness slant, but I’d be interested in seeing people from the MBSR, MBCT, and MBRP communities tackling the issue.

  • Thank you for any other informative site. Where else could I get that type of info written in such an ideal manner? I’ve a challenge that I am simply now working on, and I have been on the look out for such information.

  • Join the Conversation!

    Before posting, please read our blog moderation guidelines.

    Post a Comment:


    (Required, will be published)

    (Required, but will not be published)

    (Optional)

    Books and CDs by Dr. Elisha Goldstein:

    Available Now
    A Mindfulness-Based 
Stress Reduction Workbook
    Available Now

    Mindful Solutions for Stress, Anxiety and Depression Mindful Solutions for Addiction and Relapse Prevention
    Mindfulness Audio CD's by Elisha Goldstein
    Recent Comments
    • Sharon: John, Feel what you need to feel. By visiting your wife, you will have no regrets. You will not look back...
    • Owen Spear: I recently wrote a book on mindfulness and sex, and I was pondering the same issue you have mentioned...
    • Kate at Stress Relief Workshop: There are several lovely ideas in this video. I love the idea of ‘checking...
    • John Burik: Nice way to begin my Sunday morning. What struck me about the “two worlds” is the realization...
    • Giedre: Thank you for sharing such a good idea. I will definitely try using it with my clients!
    Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter



    Find a Therapist


    Users Online: 4438
    Join Us Now!