Mindfulness and Psychotherapy

Why Keep Your Heart Open in Hell?

By Elisha Goldstein, Ph.D.

In my own life I have always felt stories and metaphors with morals have been powerful in helping me really get a message on a deeper level. This is no secret, that’s why Chicken Soup for the Soul and Aesop’s Fables have been so enduringly popular.  There is something about them that seem to hit us on an emotional level where their messages really stick. When I was starting out as a Psychologist I set up times with leading therapists to glean their wisdom to support me in really getting started on the right foot. I asked one therapist the question, “In your time as a therapist, what has been one of the greatest things you’ve learned?” He looked up and began to think. After a few moments, he looked back in my eyes and said, “While people may come in to see me once a week or so, the real therapy happens in their daily lives. I could spend an entire session with a couple trying to explain and enact the therapeutic concept of remaining present, empathic, and compassionate to the other even during difficult times and while this may support them in the moment, the message may or may not stick with them throughout the week where the real therapy occurs. But, if I ask ‘Can you keep your heart open in hell’, this may really stay with them and they are more likely to be able to grab it when difficulty arises. If they use it during difficult times that is when change really happens.  

“Can you keep your heart open in hell” to me, says, in those moments when we are wrought by our habits that keep us stuck in perpetual avoidance of what’s uncomfortable or foreign, can we stay with that discomfort and open up to ourselves or another with a  sense of compassion and love. What difference would this make? Yes, what difference would it make if we were able to put ourselves in another shoes a bit more often instead of reacting with defensiveness or attacks? What difference would it make if we were able to sit with the sadness or fear, sending ourselves loving kindness, instead of reaching for that next piece of chocolate cake, ice cream, or substance of choice? What difference would it make if we actually allowed ourselves to love or be loved, instead of constantly keeping all feelings at bay in order just to feel a false sense of safety?

The effectiveness of these words hits me on a fundamental level as someone who has been on both sides of the couch. How can we get in touch with our hearts a bit more, especially in the midst of our most difficult moments?

Attitudes to cultivate to keep our hearts open in hell:

Allowing the words and attitudes of acknowledging, allowing, letting be, non-judgment, non-striving, compassion, and empathy to pervade our minds during these times can be an enormous help during difficult times.

Learning to keep our hearts open in hell may just be what is necessary to break free from our habitual patterns that bind us, and into the lives we want.

Are there any stories that have touched you or influenced you? Please feel free to share these or any questions below. Your interactions provide a living wisdom for us all to benefit from


Comments


View Comments / Leave a Comment

This post currently has 3 comments/trackbacks.
You can read the comments or leave your own thoughts.

Trackbacks

From Psych Central's website:
PsychCentral (July 31, 2009)




    Last reviewed: 30 Jul 2009

APA Reference
Goldstein, E. (2009). Why Keep Your Heart Open in Hell?. Psych Central. Retrieved on February 14, 2012, from http://blogs.psychcentral.com/mindfulness/2009/07/why-keep-your-heart-open-in-hell/

 

Books and CDs by Dr. Elisha Goldstein:

Pre-Order Now!
A Mindfulness-Based 
Stress Reduction Workbook
Available Now

Mindful Solutions for Stress, Anxiety and Depression Mindful Solutions for Addiction and Relapse Prevention
Mindfulness Audio CD's by Elisha Goldstein
Recent Comments
  • Marek: Very interesting articel! Thank you very much for sharing your thoughts!
  • Judith Waring: As a Gestalt psychotherapist I can relate to some of your article. I focus with clients on the present...
  • ibivi: The minutiae of daily living just isn’t that interesting. I found this out while taking transit to work...
  • ThelmaNancy Greene: Thank you for sharing your expertise concerning the matter of Urge Surfing. At the moment I am a...
  • Viki: It’s so important to learn to be mindful Just the other night I was upset about something and I wanted to...
Subscribe to Our Weekly Newsletter



Find a Therapist


Users Online: 5085
Join Us Now!