Regarding Rhetoric, 'Suicide' Offers No Leeway
The other day, I explained that while I didn’t think her intentions were malicious, I thought it pretty cool of Twilight star Kristen Stewart to clarify why she used the word “psychotic” when she described some of the fan situations she’s experienced.
Psychotherapy Brown Bag owner Michael Anestis agreed, and chimed in with his thoughts about “ignorance” versus “malice,” asking what I thought about Senator Grassley’s comment on AIG executives and suicide. (In case you missed it, Senator Grassley remarked that AIG representatives should follow the Japanese example, take a deep bow , and then either “resign, or go commit suicide” – class act, that one.)
I’ll tell you what I think.
I think that even though the majority of the country is forming an AIG lynch mob, Senator Chuck Grassley’s comment was the very worst mix of both ignorance and malice. Where Kristen Stewart is an 18-year-old trying to get her bearings in the world of celebrity, Senator Grassley is a 75-year-old who’s served in the senate for 28 years. His “ignorance” can’t be blamed on youth and lack of experience, and he’s able to spread his malice from a government position.
I think that while there’s a bit of leeway when it comes to using words like “crazy,” “insane,” and some of their synonyms to describe certain shocking, unbelievable, or exciting events, there is absolutely no leeway whatsoever when it comes to suicide.
Suicide means death, Chuck, and death is permanent. Perhaps even more outrageous than your suicide suggestion is that you had the nerve to get defensive during an interview with NBC’s Domenico Montanaro, claiming “I hope you recognize rhetoric […] and I shouldn’t even have to answer that question….”:
Pressed by Shuster, who asked if Grassley had any regret for his phrasing, Grassley struck a defensive tone.
“I’ve stated that you oughta be able to tell rhetoric when you hear it,” the Iowa Republican said.
Seriously, Chuck? That is the line you’re going to feed us? That we are the ones who …










