This week, all over the internet news, is this unfortunate incident of a Texas teacher asking students to strike another student who was known to be a bully.The student identified as a bully, Aiden, is just 6 years old. The teacher asked students to hit the bully, “to teach him why bullying is bad.”

Ironically, corporal punishment is legal in some public schools but as the Reuters article points out, teachers -and not students- are the ones doling out punishments. When I read this story, it reminded me yet again how some schools are well equipped to deal with bullying while others are clearly not. Furthermore, a March 12th, 2012 article from Time reported that some of the new anti-bullying legislation implemented leaves the burden on to schools to fund required anti-bullying programs. Schools are left trying implement new programming with limited resources.

This Texas teacher clearly did not know how to appropriately address bullying. I have to wonder: why would an adult go to that extreme? To bully the bully back? Has Aiden truly learned to treat his peers with kindness and consideration? 

I attended a School Mental Health conference at Harvard this winter and had the pleasure of listening to Dr. Frank C. Sacco speak. He is the co-author of Why Anti-Bullying Programs Don’t Work.” Dr. Sacco’s philosophy (which is the same as mine and the philosophy where I work) is that the bystanders – not the bullies  – are the people with the most power to create a change and end bullying.

An entire school community must buy-in to the idea that addressing bullying by retaliatory acts is counterproductive. 

School fight photo available from Shutterstock.



View Comments / Leave a Comment

This post currently has 0 comments.
You can read the comments or leave your own thoughts.


    Last reviewed: 21 Jun 2012

APA Reference
Prudente, K. (2012). Anti-bullying Gone Awry. Psych Central. Retrieved on March 30, 2015, from



Subscribe to this Blog: Feed

Most Popular Posts
Recent Comments
  • Catherine Blair: I was a poor child who didn’t have money for lunch. I could bring my lunch but everyone else...
  • john: seems like the armchair quarterbacks dont have anything else to comment on. had i been the principal and seeing...
  • Brian: I think I’m misunderstanding something here. It seems to me you are saying research shows that bullied...
  • Fighter: I’ve been a bystander twice, once with some authority and once without any. Both times I was unable to...
  • Alana: Thank you for sharing this interesting article.
Find a Therapist
Enter ZIP or postal code

Users Online: 12240
Join Us Now!